Maple Peanut Butter French Toast Cups

Maple Peanut Butter French Toast Cups can be enjoyed any time of day! Breakfast, snack or dessert! Filled with creamy maple peanut butter center this sweet treat is something that everyone will enjoy! Oh, and they are really amazing smothered in extra maple syrup!

It may not be very cold here in Arizona yet, but all of my cravings for fall treats and comfort foods have kicked in! And when you can create something like Maple Peanut Butter French Toast Cups to satisfy both your fall sweet and comfort food cravings it’s a double win! And that is exactly how these came about! I mean, can you think of a better way to relax on a Sunday morning than in your pj’s all nice and comfy enjoying these sweet little Maple Peanut Butter French Toast Cups? I know I can’t!

The Maple Peanut Butter French Toast Cups are a great alternative to standing over the oven making french toast piece by piece! They are also much quicker than your normal baked french toast! Plus, single serve? Who doesn’t love treats that are made for one? I know it makes me feel more special!

I used egg whites i  nstead of whole eggs to amp up the protein and then filled it with my favorite maple peanut powder to give it that decadent, melty peanut butter center! Of course, I had to use the maple flavor because a) it’s my favorite and b) maple is such a great fall flavor!

Ok, I know you are drooling and ready to just go make these already!

Maple Peanut Butter Stuffed French Toast Cups Print Author: Sarah Recipe type: Breakfast Serves: 6 Ingredients

  • 1 cup milk
  • ½ cup vanilla egg whites
  • 1 large egg
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract
  • sweetener, to taste
  • 2 tsp ground cinnamon
  • 8 slices bread
  • ½ cup maple peanut butter powder
  • 4-6 tbs milk or water


  1. Preheat oven to 400 degrees
  2. Coat 6 muffin cups with nonstick spray
  3. Whisk together all ingredients through cinnamon
  4. Cut bread into squares
  5. Soak bread in egg mixture
  6. Place bread cubes into muffin cups
  7. Bake about 18-22 minutes
  8. While French toast is baking
  9. Combine maple peanut powder with 4-6 tables of milk or water (you are looking for a peanut butter-like consistency)
  10. When French toast cups are done, top each with the maple peanut powder
  11. Enjoy with maple syrup


P.S – these are also amazing for large Sunday brunch get togethers!

Don’t forget to PIN this recipe to make again and again!

What is your favorite maple recipe? Have you ever tried making french toast cups before?

Maple Peanut Butter French Toast Cups via @fitchick428

Our Latest Posts

How to slice tri tip

How to Slice tri tip, Cut, and Grill Tri-Tip the Youtube

Step-by-Step Guide – Learn How to Slice Tri Tip Like a Pro in Just a Few Simple Movements When it comes to cooking tri tip,…

What does savory mean

What Does Savory Definition Meaning in Collins English Dictionary

Anchovy vs sardine

Anchovies vs Sardines: Exploring the Key Differences Between

Anchovy vs Sardine – Which Fish is the Better Choice for Your Health? When it comes to seafood, anchovies and sardines are two of the…

how to store sourdough bread

Best Practices to How Store Sourdough Bread

Most popular posts

Perfect Substitutes: Shortening and Butter Flavored Alternatives

Turkey, Kale and Bean Stew

Turkey, Kale & Bean Stew Serves: 6 This recipe is featured in my new cookbook! Get the cookbook and a free password for all protected…

Ooey Gooey Baked Banana Chocolate Chip Oatmeal 1

Ooey Gooey Baked Banana Chocolate Chip Oatmeal

Happy Friday! I hope you had a great week! Per usual mine was busy but in a great way! I have been working on some exciting…

Apple Cider Jame Squares 1

Apple Cider Jam Squares

Happy Halloween Friends! I hope you have had a great week! Although, I do not have any ‘scary’ recipes to share with you today, I…